Obviously, Ted was a little strong for the pack. Despite some
generally impressive comeback seasons, this group unfortunately
didn't stay around much longer. Hank Greenberg retired the next
year; Joe DiMaggio retired five years later. This was Charlie
Keller's last year as a regular; he hung around as a bit player for
a few years. Only Williams and Mickey Vernon had long careers. While
the war had an obvious effect on players by cutting holes out of their
careers, I wonder if it was responsible for a lot of early retirements
as well. Maybe some guys were just too beat up, physically and
mentally, to continue.
Mickey Vernon may have had his best
season. Vernon was 28 years old, and had just spent two years overseas.
Despite those two lost years, Vernon managed to play 20 seasons, and hammer
out 2495 hits. Vernon also played on seven All-Star teams — but the truth
is, he was a very inconsistent player. After his great season this year,
Vernon went into a slump for five years. His career probably should have
ended, except that Washington was a terrible team, and had no one better
to replace him.
Then, without warning, Vernon won another
batting title in 1953. He had four straight good years, and even added
some power to his game. He had his last good year with Cleveland in 1958,
at age 40. Had Vernon not slumped so badly in mid-career,
he would be in the Hall Of Fame. Instead, he was just a good first baseman
who was occasionally great.
Bobby Doerr and Johnny Pesky, both Red Sox players, were the
best of this group. With Williams, they formed a powerful nucleus
that somehow managed to not win the pennant ever again, despite
coming awfully close several times.
George Kell had his first good season, at age
24. Kell played third base for 15 years, and is now in the Hall Of Fame.
He was a singles and doubles hitter; he consistently hit around .320 in his
prime, and won the batting title in 1949. In 1950, he led the league with a career-high 56 doubles. He was also a very fine defensive player. Kell retired
with 2054 hits, and a career .306 average. He also had
a brother named Skeeter Kell, who played for one season in 1952.
I have to consider Kell won of the weaker
players in the Hall; he was a heck of a player from 1946-1951, but he rarely
played a full season, and he didn't age very well. He was the best third baseman
in an era that didn't have many good third basemen; I don't think he
was nearly as good as Ron Santo or Ken Boyer or Harland Clift, or some others
who are not in The Hall.